Catalan independence can be good or bad - it depends on the Catalan people to make it good, or else it likely will be bad.
Headlines and commentary across both Eastern and Western media have
mainly focused on the Catalan independence referendum and the actions of
Spanish police and the Spanish government's attempts to disrupt polls.
However, little is being said about what the real implications of
Catalan independence may be. What do those politicians in Catalonia in
favor of independence seek to do with it should they succeed? Will they
create a Catalonia that serves the best interests of the people? Or
serve the EU and NATO more efficiently and eagerly than a united Spain
There are 5 points those following this conflict should know and keep in mind as events unfold:
1. Catalonia has a formidable industrialized economy relative to
other regions of Spain, with a GDP and population just exceeding those
of nations like Scotland or Singapore, and likely could achieve and
sustain independence from Spain.
2. NATO appears eager to encourage independence and would welcome
what they expect to be a robust military capability to add to their
wars of global aggression.
An article published in 2014 by the Atlantic Council - a Fortune 500-funded NATO think tank - titled, "The Military Implications of Scottish and Catalonian Secession," would state:
Catalonia has 7.3 million people, with more than $300 billion in GDP.
Spending just 1.6% of that on defense provides over $4.5 billion
annually, or roughly the budget of Denmark, which has well-regarded and
efficient armed forces. Catalonian military plans are more vague, but so
far, they emphasize the navy. With excellent ports in Barcelona and
Tarragona, Catalonia is well-positioned as a minor naval power, ‘with
the Mediterranean as our strategic environment, and NATO as our
framework’, as the nationalists’ think-tank on defense argues. The rough
plans call for a littoral security group of a few hundred sailors at
first. After a few years, Catalonia would assume responsibility as "a
main actor in the Mediterranean," with land-based maritime patrol
aircraft and small surface combatants. Eventually, the nationalist
ambition may include an expeditionary group with a light assault carrier
and hundreds of marines, to take a serious role in collective security.
The Atlantic Council piece would emphatically conclude that:
If accurately characterized by the few white papers that have
surfaced, the separatists’ position suggests a valuable and refreshing
view of specialization in collective defense: build a navy that is
comparatively focused on influencing events ashore.
3. Pro-independence Catalan politicians appear to enthusiastically support Catalonia's membership in NATO.
...when the next Afghanistan comes, Catalan blood will also be spilled.
A 2014 article titled, "Catalan PM confirms NATO membership, commitment to collective security," stated:
Prime Minister Artur Mas explicitly confirmed Catalonia is seeking
NATO membership. In a recent interview with the Italian daily La
Reppublica, Catalan Prime Minister Artur Mas explained that an
independent Catalonia sees herself at the heart of NATO. This is in line
with Catalonia's commitment to the international community, the
principle of collective security, international law, and the rule of law
The article also claims:
Catalonia seeks freedom, not to avoid the inescapable
responsibilities that come hand in hand with it, but to fully exercise
them side by side with partners and allies. Catalans understand fully
that freedom never comes without cost, and that whereas independence
means government of the people, by the people, and for the people,
instead of alien rule, it also means that they will not be able to look
the other way when a crisis or challenge arises. They understand that
when the next Afghanistan comes, Catalan blood will also be spilled.
In essence, Catalan politicians appear eagerly committed not only to
NATO, but to the foreign wars of aggression it wages, and spilling the
blood of its people to help NATO fight them.
4. Some Catalan politicians have begun planning for its military's integration into NATO.
The pro-independence Catalan National Assembly's Defense Policy Working Group has stated in a 2014 paper titled, "Dimensions of the Catalan Defence Forces: Naval Forces (Executive Summary)," that:
The Mediterranean: our strategic environment. NATO: our framework
must participate in SNMG2 (Standing NATO Maritime Group 2; formerly
Standing Naval Force Mediterranean), a component of the NRF (NATO
It would also be convenient to participate in the SNMCMG2 (Standing NATO Mine Countermeasures Group 2).
5. Like "Kurdistan," any sort of "independence" is meaningless if
the resulting state finds itself utterly dependent and entwined with
Western hegemony and the institutions that maintain it - especially at
the cost of member states and proxies - be they Kurdish or Catalan.
That Catalonia's politicians have already openly and eagerly pledged
Catalan blood and treasure to foreign interests and the wars they seek
to fight across the globe, suggests that the notion of Catalonia
actually achieving any sort of "independence" is actually Catalonia
simply becoming more dependent on an even greater master, and one even
These 5 points should be considered by those for and against Catalan
independence. While Catalonia could create for itself a lasting and
meaningful independence underpinned by peace and prosperity for its
people, it appears that many in senior leadership positions intend to
simply shift Catalonia's subservience from Madrid to Brussels.
Further questions regarding Catalonia's economy remain - including what
an independent Catalonia might do to help feed larger, foreign
corporations who may seek to circumvent barriers and obstacles in
Spain's current economic climate, and exploit an "independent"
Catalonia, its people, markets, and resources. Unfortunately, such
economic policies and their fallout may unfold long after it is possible
for the people of Catalonia to do anything about it.
For the Catalan people dedicated to independence, they must find and use
the local, socioeconomic leverage necessary to direct their potentially
independent nation toward a trajectory that best serves them and their
future - not a handful of Catalan politicians eagerly serving interests
in Brussels, London, or Washington.
By Tony Cartalucci